How Parents Can Spot an Excellent Tutor
- Khanh Do
- Sep 16
- 4 min read
With over two decades of experience tutoring, interviewing, and partnering with tutors, I’ve learned what separates excellent tutors from average ones. Parents can hear most of the signals during a short phone interview, then confirm them with references that provide real insight.
Look for Pattern Spotters
Strong tutors do more than correct wrong answers. They identify patterns in mistakes and trace them back to the root. For example, if a student misses word problems, the real issue may be reading comprehension, not math.
Phone interview test: Ask, “How do you figure out why a student misses a problem?” The answer should sound like a clear process, not guesswork.
Gauge Genuine Enthusiasm
The best tutors light up when they teach. Energy and passion are contagious, and students feed off them. Tutors who are only in it for the paycheck rarely inspire lasting motivation.
Phone interview test: Ask, “What do you enjoy most about tutoring this subject?” Flat or generic answers signal low engagement.
Ask About Independence Building
Excellent tutors equip students with strategies to solve problems on their own. They do not just provide answers.
Phone interview test: Ask, “What strategies will my child be able to use independently after working with you?” Strong tutors should mention concrete skills such as annotation, outlining, or step-by-step problem solving.
Check Flexibility in Teaching Style
Not every student learns the same way. Seasoned tutors have multiple approaches such as visual models, analogies, drills, or breaking problems into smaller steps. If one method fails, they pivot.
Phone interview test: Ask, “What do you do if my child doesn’t understand your explanation?” Look for a willingness to adapt, not repeat the same explanation.
Confirm Progress Tracking
Progress should never be a mystery. Great tutors use tools like short quizzes, updated score graphs, or writing samples to show growth.
Phone interview test: Ask, “How will I know if my child is improving?” Avoid vague answers like, “I’ll let you know.”
Notice Professionalism During the Call
The phone call itself is a preview of their tutoring. Notice whether they show up on time, ask about your child, speak clearly, and outline next steps. A sloppy call predicts sloppy sessions.
Pay Attention to Connection
The relationship matters as much as the lesson. A student who feels respected and encouraged will thrive. A tutor who makes them feel small will not succeed long term.
Parent check: After the call, ask yourself, “Would my child feel comfortable and motivated with this person?”
Verify With References That Matter
Strong tutors welcome references. The goal is useful detail, not generic praise. Ask for one recent reference and one that goes back at least six months. If confidentiality is an issue, ask for anonymized progress samples such as before-and-after essays, math error logs, or score trends.
Reference call script:
What was your student’s starting point and goal?
What changed after four to six sessions?
What concrete skill or habit stuck after the tutor left?
How did the tutor handle setbacks?
Would you hire this tutor again for another child?
What to listen for: specifics, clear skills, and calm handling of challenges. If all you hear is, “They were great, you’ll love them,” without details, the reference is not useful.
Red Flags to Watch For
No clear plan
If the tutor cannot describe how the first sessions will run, progress will stall.
Too much hand holding
Tutors who provide answers instead of building skills create dependence, not independence.
No progress tracking
If there is no system for measuring growth, you will always be guessing.
Lack of enthusiasm
Low energy from the tutor leads to low energy from the student.
Poor time management or suspicious availability
Having many students is not a problem if sessions start on time and stay focused. Red flags include rushed lessons or constant rescheduling. On the other hand, a tutor who is always free may lack demand for a reason.
Over promising
Be cautious of guarantees like, “I can raise your child’s score by 300 points in a month.” Strong tutors focus on steady, realistic improvement.
Weak connection with your child
If your child dreads sessions after a first meeting, the fit is wrong.
Quick Parent Checklist
Ask yourself after the phone interview:
Did the tutor explain a clear diagnostic process?
Did they sound enthusiastic and specific?
Did they emphasize building independence?
Did they show a plan for tracking progress?
Did they handle the call professionally?
Did they provide strong references without hesitation?
If you can answer yes to these, you are on the right track.
The best tutors do more than review homework. They diagnose patterns, build durable skills, track progress, and inspire confidence. A thoughtful phone interview combined with strong references allows parents to spot these qualities early and avoid costly mistakes. Choose the tutor who brings process, passion, and proof, and your student will feel the difference within weeks.
Comments